Blog Post

We all agree Customer Lifetime Value is important, but there’s not much agreement after that.

Peter Rivett-Jones • 5 April 2024

The challenges of Customer Lifetime Value (CLV)

The challenges of Customer Lifetime Value (CLV)

Customer Lifetime Value is one of those phrases that is bandied about in CRM Marketing. You’ll go to a meeting and when CLV is mentioned everyone will nod their head, someone will say how important it is and the head nodding will continue. However, if you ever then enter into a conversation about what is meant by Customer Lifetime Value, the nodding often quickly stops. Head scratching and disagreement often prevails.


Customer Lifetime Value is a fantastic concept. The idea that you measure customer value over a longer term makes perfect sense. If you spend a small fortune recruiting a customer why would you try to determine a customer’s ROI over their first year of sales. That customer is going to be a customer for years to come. The principle of CLV is easily understood but the reality of actually defining that value and measuring it is another matter. 
There are many different calculations for CLV, some involving churn rates and gross margin but I like to keep it simple. For me CLV = average value of a purchase x number of times the customer will buy each year x average length of the customer relationship (in years).


The first challenge comes in who do we mean by the customer. Are we taking the average customer lifetime value across the entire customer base or we referring to an individual customer or customer segment. The problem with taking averages is that it often masks the true picture. Most companies have some form of Pareto effect or 80:20 bias in their customer base - see our previous Blog The top 20% of customers generating 80% of revenue and whilst the numbers do differ slightly by client and sector, the bottom line is that there will be great disparities in customer value, purchase frequency and number of years active as a customer. You are probably better looking at CLV by key customer segments either based on some form of extended RFV (Recency, Frequency, Value Model) or customer types & profiles. 


The second challenge is agreeing the length of the customer relationship. In the automotive sector where there are long purchase cycles are we calculating the customer relationship based on consecutive purchases or are we looking at the actual lifetime of the customer. As I’ve discussed in a previous blog in sectors like retail defining the length of a customer relationship and therefore lapse rates is tricky as customers typically spread their custom across multiple retailers and customer spend can fluctuate from one retailer to another.


New research by Econsultancy, carried out in association with Sitecore and comprising 900 responses, shows the CLV concerns of client-side organisations, agencies, vendors and consultancies.  The study reveals that more than three quarters of company respondents (76 per cent) either somewhat agree (25 per cent) or strongly agree (51 per cent) that CLV is an important concept for their organisation. However, only 11 per cent strongly agree that they are able to measure it. Only 6 per cent of agencies strongly agree that their clients have a handle on CLV measurement.


Customer Lifetime Value as a tool can be beneficial, but only if it isn’t considered an absolute. Not every customer is going to have the same value. however, this tool can help to position a business to be stronger against their competition in the future.  If you understand your CLV well, that can help shape your business strategy to keep loyal customers, rather than investing the resources in acquiring new ones. If your customer lifetime value is on the rise, that could mean you should continue to invest in product development or your customer service teams. If your CLV is declining, that might tell you your latest marketing strategy might need a reboot. 

Customer Lifetime Value helps you understand and gauge current customer loyalty. If customers continue to purchase from you time and time again, that’s usually a good sign that you’re doing the right things in your business. 


Further Reading


CLV is key to identifying your best customers, and they are key to building a stronger and more sustainable business. In this recent article we talked about the fact that not all customers are equal and why understanding your best customers are the key to business success.


CRM MARKETING BLOGS

Customer Segmentation: Should You Start with Data or Qualitative Research?
5 December 2024
In this blog, we’ll explore the benefits and drawbacks of starting your segmentation process with customer data versus qualitative research, helping you determine the best path for your CRM Marketing strategy.
Why Open Rates Can No Longer Be Trusted as an Accurate Measure of Email Engagement
4 December 2024
Email open rates are becoming increasingly unreliable as a measure of engagement, it’s time to reconsider how we assess the effectiveness of email campaigns. Here’s why open rates no longer paint the full picture—and why businesses should start looking beyond this metric to truly understand how their emails are performing.
The Challenge of Measuring Always-On CRM Marketing Programmes
4 December 2024
In today’s hyper-connected world, always-on CRM Marketing has become a key strategy for brands looking to build long-lasting relationships with their customers. However, while the benefits of maintaining ongoing, personalised communication with customers are clear, measuring the effectiveness of these programs can be quite challenging.
High-Value Customers May Not Be Loyal – What to Do About It
4 December 2024
High-value customers may not always be loyal. In fact, some of your best spenders may be the ones most at risk of jumping ship. Why is that? And what can businesses do to ensure these high-value customers remain loyal and continue to drive revenue?
Is Share of Wallet the Best Indicator of Loyalty for UK Supermarkets?
4 December 2024
While share of wallet can offer valuable insights into purchasing behaviour and customer retention, the question remains: is it the best indicator of loyalty for UK supermarkets?
Can a Customer Truly Be Loyal, or Do We Need to Redefine What Loyalty Means?
4 December 2024
Gone are the days when a loyal customer was someone who bought from the same brand year after year, no matter what. The modern consumer has more options, more access to information, and more power than ever before. So, the question we need to ask ourselves is: Can a customer truly be loyal anymore? Or do we need to rethink what loyalty actually means?
The Single Customer View: The Holy Grail of CRM Marketing That Few Companies Achieve
4 December 2024
In this blog, we’ll explore why the Single Customer View {SCV} in CRM Marketing remains an elusive goal for many businesses, why it’s so important, and how companies can get closer to realising it.
Can a Customer Have a Relationship with a Bottle of Bleach? Exploring the Limits of CRM Marketing
4 December 2024
Can CRM Marketing truly work for all products, or are there limits to the types of products that can spark genuine emotional engagement? For instance, can a customer develop a relationship with something as utilitarian and seemingly impersonal as a bottle of bleach?
How to Use Multiple Channels (Not Just Email) in CRM Marketing
3 December 2024
In this blog, we’ll explore why it’s essential to go beyond email and how you can effectively incorporate a range of channels to engage customers, drive loyalty, and improve your overall marketing performance.
Why Excluding Single-Purchase Customers Gives a True Picture of a Company’s Customer Base
3 December 2024
In this blog, we’ll explore why excluding single-purchase customers is crucial for better insights and smarter business decisions. So-called single-purchase customers—those who buy once and never return—can distort the true picture of a company’s customer base.
Show More
Share by: