Blog Post

Can a Customer Truly Be Loyal, Or Do We Need to Redefine What Loyalty Means?

4 December 2024
In the competitive world of business, customer loyalty has long been seen as the holy grail. Brands strive to build lasting relationships with their customers, hoping to turn one-time buyers into repeat purchasers, and eventually, brand advocates. But in today’s fast-paced, hyper-connected, and choice-driven market, customer loyalty might not mean what it used to.

Gone are the days when a loyal customer was someone who bought from the same brand year after year, no matter what. The modern consumer has more options, more access to information, and more power than ever before. So, the question we need to ask ourselves is: Can a customer truly be loyal anymore? Or do we need to rethink what loyalty actually means?

The Traditional Definition of Loyalty

Traditionally, customer loyalty has been defined as repeat purchases over time. Brands have measured it based on how often a customer returns to buy their products, how much they spend, and whether they stay committed to one brand, rather than shopping around. Loyalty programs were built on this idea—offering rewards for every purchase, discounts for repeat buyers, and incentives for customers to keep coming back.

Under this traditional definition, loyalty is a linear relationship: the more a customer buys, the more loyal they are. The assumption is that loyalty is a direct result of satisfaction and value—a satisfied customer keeps returning to the brand they trust.

However, in a rapidly evolving marketplace, this definition is becoming increasingly outdated. The reality is that modern consumers are much more complex, and loyalty is no longer so easily defined by purchase frequency alone.

Why Customer Loyalty Is Harder to Achieve Today

1. The Power of Choice

Consumers today are flooded with choices. Thanks to the internet and social media, it’s easier than ever to compare products, read reviews, and switch between brands. Loyalty is harder to maintain when there are always new alternatives and competing products vying for attention.

For example, a customer might buy a pair of shoes from a well-known retailer today but may switch to a competitor offering a better discount or new product tomorrow. In this environment, loyalty can feel fragile. While the customer may return to the brand for another purchase, it’s often motivated by convenience, price, or a specific need rather than deep emotional attachment or loyalty.
2. The Influence of Experience Over Product

In today’s experience-driven economy, customers value experiences more than ever. Whether it’s the ease of online shopping, a seamless checkout process, or a personalised in-store experience, it’s no longer just about the product—it’s about the experience. Customers are more likely to remain loyal to brands that offer great service, an engaging brand experience, and real-time interaction on their terms.

For example, a customer may continue to purchase from a retailer not because they love the product itself, but because of the excellent customer service, the personalisation they receive, or the convenience of fast delivery. If another brand can offer a similar product but a better experience, they may jump ship without thinking twice.
3. Social and Ethical Expectations

Today’s consumers are also deeply influenced by social, ethical, and environmental concerns. A customer who was once loyal to a brand for its high-quality products may suddenly reconsider if that brand is not aligning with their values. Whether it’s concerns about sustainability, ethical sourcing, or corporate transparency, loyalty can be fragile if a brand fails to meet these new expectations.

For example, a UK consumer who has been buying from a specific fashion brand for years may switch to a competitor that offers more eco-friendly products or has better corporate social responsibility (CSR) practices. In this way, loyalty is no longer just about the transactional relationship; it’s about whether a brand reflects the customer’s values.
4. The Rise of Subscription Models and Instant Gratification

The growth of subscription services and the demand for instant gratification have also changed the landscape of loyalty. Customers may subscribe to a service or brand out of convenience and accessibility, but their loyalty is often based on short-term factors like price, value, and immediate satisfaction, rather than long-term commitment. If a brand no longer meets those short-term needs, customers can easily cancel and switch to a competitor.

Moreover, subscription fatigue is a real issue. As more brands push subscription-based services or loyalty schemes, customers may find it overwhelming or confusing to manage all of their subscriptions, leading to churn and a decrease in brand loyalty.

Redefining Loyalty: What Does It Mean Today?

In light of these challenges, it’s clear that customer loyalty needs to be redefined. Rather than viewing loyalty as a simple, linear path based on repeat purchases, we need to consider the deeper, more nuanced factors that influence a customer’s relationship with a brand. Here are a few ways loyalty is evolving:

1. Emotional Loyalty vs. Transactional Loyalty

Traditional loyalty is often transactional: customers return because they get something in return (discounts, rewards, etc.). However, today’s loyalty is much more emotional. A customer might not buy from a brand for months, but if they feel a strong emotional connection with the company—due to shared values, trust, or a positive experience—they will return when the time is right.

Brands that foster emotional loyalty through storytelling, shared values, and exceptional experiences are more likely to build lasting relationships with customers, even if those customers are not making regular purchases.

2. Brand Advocacy Over Repeat Purchases

In today’s interconnected world, brand advocacy is the new loyalty. Customers are more likely to recommend a brand to their friends or followers on social media than ever before. Word of mouth is a powerful driver of business, and loyal customers are often those who not only continue to purchase but also actively promote the brand to their networks.

Brands should focus on turning customers into advocates by delivering exceptional experiences, asking for reviews, and encouraging social sharing. In this way, a brand can maintain loyalty without relying solely on repeat purchases.

3. Loyalty Is Now About Trust and Value Alignment

Customers are increasingly loyal to brands they trust and whose values align with their own. This means that a customer might stay loyal to a company not because they’ve been buying from it for years, but because they trust the company to provide value, quality, and ethical practices.

For example, a UK consumer might remain loyal to a beauty brand because they trust it to use natural ingredients, engage in ethical business practices, and prioritize sustainability. Even if that consumer purchases from competitors occasionally, the trust and alignment with values will keep them coming back over time.

4. Loyalty as a Dynamic, Ongoing Relationship

Today, loyalty isn’t static—it’s an ongoing, evolving relationship. Consumers might drift in and out of loyalty depending on their circumstances, needs, and expectations. Brands need to engage with customers at various stages of their relationship to keep them connected.

Customer loyalty isn’t about locking someone in; it’s about engagement, communication, and value. A brand that regularly communicates with customers, listens to their needs, and adapts its offerings based on feedback is more likely to retain loyalty, even if that loyalty is not always a straight line.

How Can Brands Adapt to the Changing Nature of Loyalty?

• Focus on building emotional connections: Don’t just sell products—create a brand experience that resonates with your customers’ values, desires, and aspirations.
• Use data to personalise: Leverage customer data to deliver personalised offers, content, and experiences that align with individual needs and preferences.
• Engage with customers across channels: Use social media, email, and other touchpoints to stay connected with customers and encourage two-way communication.
• Be transparent and authentic: Consumers want to buy from brands they trust. Be clear about your values, practices, and the way you conduct business.
• Encourage advocacy: Reward customers for sharing their experiences and promoting your brand to their networks.

Conclusion

Customer loyalty is no longer a simple, one-dimensional concept. It’s a dynamic and multifaceted relationship that extends beyond repeat purchases. Today’s consumers are more discerning, more empowered, and more focused on value than ever before. Brands that can build emotional loyalty, offer exceptional experiences, and align with customers’ values are the ones that will succeed in this new era of customer loyalty.

So, can a customer truly be loyal? The answer depends on how we define loyalty. It’s no longer just about transactional purchases—it’s about creating deep, lasting relationships that are built on trust, value, and shared experiences. And for brands, this means redefining loyalty and thinking beyond just the next sale. 

CRM MARKETING BLOGS

Why Open Rates Can No Longer Be Trusted as an Accurate Measure of Email Engagement
4 December 2024
Email open rates are becoming increasingly unreliable as a measure of engagement, it’s time to reconsider how we assess the effectiveness of email campaigns. Here’s why open rates no longer paint the full picture—and why businesses should start looking beyond this metric to truly understand how their emails are performing.
The Challenge of Measuring Always-On CRM Marketing Programmes
4 December 2024
In today’s hyper-connected world, always-on CRM Marketing has become a key strategy for brands looking to build long-lasting relationships with their customers. However, while the benefits of maintaining ongoing, personalised communication with customers are clear, measuring the effectiveness of these programs can be quite challenging.
High-Value Customers May Not Be Loyal – What to Do About It
4 December 2024
High-value customers may not always be loyal. In fact, some of your best spenders may be the ones most at risk of jumping ship. Why is that? And what can businesses do to ensure these high-value customers remain loyal and continue to drive revenue?
Is Share of Wallet the Best Indicator of Loyalty for UK Supermarkets?
4 December 2024
While share of wallet can offer valuable insights into purchasing behaviour and customer retention, the question remains: is it the best indicator of loyalty for UK supermarkets?
The Single Customer View: The Holy Grail of CRM Marketing That Few Companies Achieve
4 December 2024
In this blog, we’ll explore why the Single Customer View {SCV} in CRM Marketing remains an elusive goal for many businesses, why it’s so important, and how companies can get closer to realising it.
Can a Customer Have a Relationship with a Bottle of Bleach? Exploring the Limits of CRM Marketing
4 December 2024
Can CRM Marketing truly work for all products, or are there limits to the types of products that can spark genuine emotional engagement? For instance, can a customer develop a relationship with something as utilitarian and seemingly impersonal as a bottle of bleach?
How to Use Multiple Channels (Not Just Email) in CRM Marketing
3 December 2024
In this blog, we’ll explore why it’s essential to go beyond email and how you can effectively incorporate a range of channels to engage customers, drive loyalty, and improve your overall marketing performance.
Why Excluding Single-Purchase Customers Gives a True Picture of a Company’s Customer Base
3 December 2024
In this blog, we’ll explore why excluding single-purchase customers is crucial for better insights and smarter business decisions. So-called single-purchase customers—those who buy once and never return—can distort the true picture of a company’s customer base.
Is Return on Investment (ROI) a Fantasy in Today’s Digital World?
3 December 2024
In the world of marketing, Return on Investment (ROI) has long been the golden metric. But in today’s complex and highly fragmented digital landscape, is ROI still the ultimate measure of marketing success? Or has it become a fantasy—an outdated, overly simplistic metric that fails to capture the true value of modern marketing efforts? Marketers also need to embrace more holistic metrics, such as Customer Lifetime Value, multi-touch attribution, and brand health indicators, to assess the true impact of their strategies.
How to Maximise Customer Engagement Rates in CRM Marketing
2 December 2024
Achieving high customer engagement rates can be tricky. It requires a nuanced approach that balances personalisation, consistent communication, and delivering value at every touchpoint. In this blog, we’ll explore actionable strategies that can help you maximise customer engagement and strengthen your relationship marketing efforts.
Show More
Share by: